“NotMr。Brayne,”saidtheDuchessofMontSt。Michel,lookinground。
“No,”saidLordGallowayinahoarse,harshvoice。“AndnotMr。NeilOBrien,Ifancy。Isawthatgentlemanwalkinginthegardenwhenthecorsewasstillwarm。”
“Ivan,”saidthedetective,“goandfetchCommandantO‘BrienandMr。Brayne。Mr。Brayne,Iknow,isfnishingacigarinthedining-room;CommandantO’Brien,Ithink,iswalkinguanddowntheconservatory。Iamnotsure。”
Thefaithfulattendantfashedfromtheroom,andbeforeanyonecouldstirorseakValentinwentonwiththesamesoldierlyswiftnessofexosition。
“Everyonehereknowsthatadeadmanhasbeenfoundinthegarden,hisheadcutcleanfromhisbody。Dr。Simon,youhaveexaminedit。Doyouthinkthattocutamansthroatlikethatwouldneedgreatforce?Or,erhas,onlyaverysharknife?”
“Ishouldsaythatitcouldnotbedonewithaknifeatall,”saidthealedoctor。
“Haveyouanythought,”resumedValentin,“ofatoolwithwhichitcouldbedone?”
“Seakingwithinmodernrobabilities,Ireallyhavent,”saidthedoctor,archinghisainfulbrows。“It‘snoteasytohackaneckthroughevenclumsily,andthiswasaverycleancut。Itcouldbedonewithabattle-axeoranoldheadsman’saxe,oranoldtwo-handedsword。”
“But,goodheavens!”criedtheDuchess,almostinhysterics,“therearentanytwo-handedswordsandbattle-axesroundhere。”
Valentinwasstillbusywiththeaerinfrontofhim。“Tellme,”hesaid,stillwritingraidly,“couldithavebeendonewithalongFrenchcavalrysabre?”
Alowknockingcameatthedoor,which,forsomeunreasonablereason,curdledeveryonesbloodliketheknockinginMacbeth。AmidthatfrozensilenceDr。Simonmanagedtosay:“Asabre-yes,Isuoseitcould。”
“Thankyou,”saidValentin。“Comein,Ivan。”
TheconfidentialIvanoenedthedoorandusheredinCommandantNeilOBrien,whomhehadfoundatlastacingthegardenagain。
TheIrishoffcerstoodudisorderedanddefantonthethreshold。“Whatdoyouwantwithme?”hecried。
“Pleasesitdown,”saidValentininleasant,leveltones。“Why,youarentwearingyoursword。Whereisit?”
“Ileftitonthelibrarytable,”saidOBrien,hisbroguedeeeninginhisdisturbedmood。“Itwasanuisance,itwasgetting-”
“Ivan,”saidValentin,“leasegoandgettheCommandantsswordfromthelibrary。”Then,astheservantvanished,“LordGallowaysayshesawyouleavingthegardenjustbeforehefoundthecorse。Whatwereyoudoinginthegarden?”
TheCommandantfunghimselfrecklesslyintoachair。“Oh,”hecriedinureIrish,“admiringthemoon。CommuningwithNature,me?”
Aheavysilencesankandendured,andattheendofitcameagainthattrivialandterribleknocking。Ivanreaeared,carryinganemtysteelscabbard。“ThisisallIcanfnd,”hesaid。
“Putitonthetable,”saidValentin,withoutlookingu。
Therewasaninhumansilenceintheroom,likethatseaofinhumansilenceroundthedockofthecondemnedmurderer。TheDuchess‘sweakexclamationshadlongagodiedaway。LordGalloway’sswollenhatredwassatisfedandevensobered。Thevoicethatcamewasquiteunexected。
“IthinkIcantellyou,”criedLadyMargaret,inthatclear,quiveringvoicewithwhichacourageouswomanseaksublicly。“IcantellyouwhatMr。OBrienwasdoinginthegarden,sinceheisboundtosilence。Hewasaskingmetomarryhim。Irefused;IsaidinmyfamilycircumstancesIcouldgivehimnothingbutmyresect。Hewasalittleangryatthat,hedidnotseemtothinkmuchofmyresect。Iwonder,”sheadded,withratherawansmile,“ifhewillcareatallforitnow。ForIofferithimnow。Iwillswearanywherethatheneverdidathinglikethis。”
LordGallowayhadedgedutohisdaughter,andwasintimidatingherinwhatheimaginedtobeanundertone。“Holdyourtongue,Maggie,”hesaidinathunderouswhiser。“Whyshouldyoushieldthefellow?Where‘shissword?Where’shisconfoundedcavalry-”
Hestoedbecauseofthesingularstarewithwhichhisdaughterwasregardinghim,alookthatwasindeedaluridmagnetforthewholegrou。
“Youoldfool!”shesaidinalowvoicewithoutretenceofiety,“whatdoyousuoseyouaretryingtorove?Itellyouthismanwasinnocentwhilewithme。Butifhewasntinnocent,hewasstillwithme。Ifhemurderedamaninthegarden,whowasitwhomusthaveseen-whomustatleasthaveknown?DoyouhateNeilsomuchastoutyourowndaughter-”
LadyGallowayscreamed。Everyoneelsesattinglingatthetouchofthosesatanictragediesthathavebeenbetweenloversbeforenow。Theysawtheroud,whitefaceoftheScotcharistocratandherlover,theIrishadventurer,likeoldortraitsinadarkhouse。Thelongsilencewasfullofformlesshistoricalmemoriesofmurderedhusbandsandoisonousaramours。
Inthecentreofthismorbidsilenceaninnocentvoicesaid:“Wasitaverylongcigar?”
Thechangeofthoughtwassosharthattheyhadtolookroundtoseewhohadsoken。
“Imean,”saidlittleFatherBrown,fromthecorneroftheroom,“ImeanthatcigarMr。Brayneisfnishing。Itseemsnearlyaslongasawalking-stick。”
DesitetheirrelevancetherewasassentaswellasirritationinValentinsfaceasheliftedhishead。
“Quiteright,”heremarkedsharly。“Ivan,goandseeaboutMr。Brayneagain,andbringhimhereatonce。”
Theinstantthefactotumhadclosedthedoor,Valentinaddressedthegirlwithanentirelynewearnestness。
“LadyMargaret,”hesaid,“weallfeel,Iamsure,bothgratitudeandadmirationforyouractinrisingaboveyourlowerdignityandexlainingtheCommandantsconduct。Butthereisahiatusstill。LordGalloway,Iunderstand,metyouassingfromthestudytothedrawing-room,anditwasonlysomeminutesafterwardsthathefoundthegardenandtheCommandantstillwalkingthere。”
“Youhavetoremember,”reliedMargaret,withafaintironyinhervoice,“thatIhadjustrefusedhim,soweshouldscarcelyhavecomebackarminarm。Heisagentleman,anyhow,andheloiteredbehind-andsogotchargedwithmurder。”
“Inthosefewmoments,”saidValentingravely,“hemightreally-”
Theknockcameagain,andIvanutinhisscarredface。
“Begardon,sir,”hesaid,“butMr。Braynehasleftthehouse。”