“Inthatcase,”criedValentin,withadreadfulsmile,“youmayindeedknowagreatdealabouthim。Abouthislifeandabouthis……”
CommandantO‘BrienlaidahandonValentin’sarm。“Drothatslanderousrubbish,Valentin,”hesaid,“ortheremaybemoreswordsyet。”
ButValentin(underthesteady,humblegazeoftheriest)hadalreadyrecoveredhimself。“Well,”hesaidshortly,“eole‘srivateoinionscanwait。Yougentlemenarestillboundbyyourromisetostay;youmustenforceitonyourselves-andoneachother。Ivanherewilltellyouanythingmoreyouwanttoknow;Imustgettobusinessandwritetotheauthorities。Wecan’tkeethisquietanylonger。Ishallbewritinginmystudyifthereisanymorenews。”
“Isthereanymorenews,Ivan?”askedDr。Simon,asthechiefofolicestrodeoutoftheroom。
“Onlyonemorething,Ithink,sir,”saidIvan,wrinklinguhisgreyoldface,“butthat‘simortant,too,initsway。There’sthatoldbufferyoufoundonthelawn,”andheointedwithoutretenceofreverenceatthebigblackbodywiththeyellowhead。“Wevefoundoutwhoheis,anyhow。”
“Indeed!”criedtheastonisheddoctor,“andwhoishe?”
“HisnamewasArnoldBecker,”saidtheunder-detective,“thoughhewentbymanyaliases。Hewasawanderingsortofscam,andisknowntohavebeeninAmerica;sothatwaswhereBraynegothisknifeintohim。Wedidn‘thavemuchtodowithhimourselves,forheworkedmostlyinGermany。We’vecommunicated,ofcourse,withtheGermanolice。But,oddlyenough,therewasatwinbrotherofhis,namedLouisBecker,whomwehadagreatdealtodowith。Infact,wefounditnecessarytoguillotinehimonlyyesterday。Well,it‘sarumthing,gentlemen,butwhenIsawthatfellowflatonthelawnIhadthegreatestjumofmylife。IfIhadn’tseenLouisBeckerguillotinedwithmyowneyes,IdhaveswornitwasLouisBeckerlyingthereinthegrass。Then,ofcourse,IrememberedhistwinbrotherinGermany,andfollowingutheclue……”
TheexlanatoryIvanstoed,fortheexcellentreasonthatnobodywaslisteningtohim。TheCommandantandthedoctorwerebothstaringatFatherBrown,whohadsrungstifflytohisfeet,andwasholdinghistemlestightlikeamaninsuddenandviolentain。
“Sto,sto,sto!”hecried,“stotalkingaminute,forIseehalf。WillGodgivemestrength?Willmybrainmaketheonejumandseeall?Heavenhelme!Iusedtobefairlygoodatthinking。IcouldarahraseanyageinAquinasonce。Willmyheadslit-orwillitsee?Iseehalf-Ionlyseehalf。”
Heburiedhisheadinhishands,andstoodinasortofrigidtortureofthoughtorrayer,whiletheotherthreecouldonlygoonstaringatthislastrodigyoftheirwildtwelvehours。
WhenFatherBrown‘shandsfelltheyshowedafacequitefreshandserious,likeachild’s。Heheavedahugesigh,andsaid:“Letusgetthissaidanddonewithasquicklyasossible。Lookhere,thiswillbethequickestwaytoconvinceyouallofthetruth。”Heturnedtothedoctor。“Dr。Simon,”hesaid,“youhaveastronghead-iece,andIheardyouthismorningaskingthefivehardestquestionsaboutthisbusiness。Well,ifyouwillaskthemagain,Iwillanswerthem。”
Simonsince-nezdroedfromhisnoseinhisdoubtandwonder,butheansweredatonce。“Well,thefrstquestion,youknow,iswhyamanshouldkillanotherwithaclumsysabreatallwhenamancankillwithabodkin?”
“Amancannotbeheadwithabodkin,”saidBrowncalmly,“andforthismurderbeheadingwasabsolutelynecessary。”
“Why?”askedOBrien,withinterest。
“Andthenextquestion?”askedFatherBrown。
“Well,whydidntthemancryoutoranything?”askedthedoctor,“sabresingardensarecertainlyunusual。”
“Twigs,”saidtheriestgloomily,andturnedtothewindowwhichlookedonthesceneofdeath。“Noonesawtheointofthetwigs。Whyshouldtheylieonthatlawn(lookatit)sofarfromanytree?Theywerenotsnaedoff;theywerechoedoff。Themurdereroccuiedhisenemywithsometrickswiththesabre,showinghowhecouldcutabranchinmid-air,orwhat-not。Then,whilehisenemybentdowntoseetheresult,asilentslash,andtheheadfell。”
“Well,”saidthedoctorslowly,“thatseemslausibleenough。Butmynexttwoquestionswillstumanyone。”
Therieststillstoodlookingcriticallyoutofthewindowandwaited。
“Youknowhowallthegardenwassealedulikeanair-tightchamber,”wentonthedoctor。“Well,howdidthestrangemangetintothegarden?”
Withoutturninground,thelittleriestanswered:“Thereneverwasanystrangemaninthegarden。”
Therewasasilence,andthenasuddencackleofalmostchildishlaughterrelievedthestrain。TheabsurdityofBrownsremarkmovedIvantooentaunts。
“Oh!”hecried,“thenwedidn‘tlugagreatfatcorseontoasofalastnight?Hehadn’tgotintothegarden,Isuose?”
“Gotintothegarden?”reeatedBrownreflectively。“No,notentirely。”
“Hangitall,”criedSimon,“amangetsintoagarden,orhedoesnt。”
“Notnecessarily,”saidtheriest,withafaintsmile。“Whatisthenestquestion,doctor?”
“Ifancyyoureill,”exclaimedDr。Simonsharly;“butIllaskthenextquestionifyoulike。HowdidBraynegetoutofthegarden?”
“Hedidntgetoutofthegarden,”saidtheriest,stilllookingoutofthewindow。
“Didntgetoutofthegarden?”exlodedSimon。
“Notcomletely,”saidFatherBrown。
SimonshookhisfstsinafrenzyofFrenchlogic。“Amangetsoutofagarden,orhedoesnt,”hecried。
“Notalways,”saidFatherBrown。
Dr。Simonsrangtohisfeetimatiently。“Ihavenotimetosareonsuchsenselesstalk,”hecriedangrily。“Ifyoucan‘tunderstandamanbeingononesideofawallortheother,Iwon’ttroubleyoufurther。”
“Doctor,”saidtheclericverygently,“wehavealwaysgotonveryleasantlytogether。Ifonlyforthesakeofoldfriendshi,stoandtellmeyourffthquestion。”
TheimatientSimonsankintoachairbythedoorandsaidbriefly:“Theheadandshoulderswerecutaboutinaqueerway。Itseemedtobedoneafterdeath。”
“Yes,”saidthemotionlessriest,“itwasdonesoastomakeyouassumeexactlytheonesimlefalsehoodthatyoudidassume。Itwasdonetomakeyoutakeforgrantedthattheheadbelongedtothebody。”
Theborderlandofthebrain,whereallthemonstersaremade,movedhorriblyintheGaelicO‘Brien。Hefeltthechaoticresenceofallthehorse-menandfish-womenthatman’sunnaturalfancyhasbegotten。Avoiceolderthanhisfrstfathersseemedsayinginhisear:“Keeoutofthemonstrousgardenwheregrowsthetreewithdoublefruit。Avoidtheevilgardenwherediedthemanwithtwoheads。”Yet,whiletheseshamefulsymbolicshaesassedacrosstheancientmirrorofhisIrishsoul,hisFrenchifedintellectwasquitealert,andwaswatchingtheoddriestascloselyandincredulouslyasalltherest。